The History of Old Fort Niagara spans more than 300 years. From the early 18th century through the War of 1812, a fort at the mouth of the Niagara River was vital, because it controlled access to the Great Lakes and the westward route to the heartland of North America. The Great Lakes and their connecting straits form a continuous body of water from the Atlantic Ocean to the center of the North American continent. To Native Americans and early Europeans, these waters provided natural highways through a rugged and heavily forested land. Perhaps the most significant barrier on this great water highway was Niagara Falls, a 182-foot cataract that required travelers to carry their boats and goods around the great falls. Whoever controlled this land detour, or portage, could exclude their rivals and enemies from the American interior.
Prior to the coming of Europeans, Native Americans intermittently used the future site of Fort Niagara as a hunting and fishing camp. During the 17th century, the French were the first Europeans to explore the Niagara Region. Twice they erected forts at the river’s mouth, the first in 1679 and the second in 1687. Neither lasted more than a year.
In 1726 French soldiers and workmen arrived at the mouth of the Niagara and began construction of Le Maison Machicoulis, a large stone building known today as the French Castle. This building, surrounded by a wooden stockade, was designed to house about 40 soldiers. The new Fort protected French interests in the region and provided a venue where Frenchmen and Native Americans could meet to negotiate and trade.
Shortly after the outbreak of the French and Indian War, the British targeted Fort Niagara for capture. The French responded by expanding the Fort to house a larger garrison and withstand artillery fire. It was not until 1759 that a British/New York Provincial army and almost 1,000 Haudenosaunee allies laid siege to the Fort. After nineteen days, the Fort’s walls had been breached by British artillery and a French relief force defeated just one mile from the Fort. The French surrendered the post and Fort Niagara became British.
By 1763 a new threat confronted Fort Niagara’s garrison. Native Americans, upset by British expansion and trade policies captured eight Great Lakes forts and laid siege to Detroit during the so-called Pontiac’s War. Although Fort Niagara was not attacked, it was a critical link in the supply line to Detroit. The following year Fort Niagara witnessed a great council between the British and several Native nations. The Fort also served as an assembly point for an expedition that relieved Detroit and returned many of the Great Lakes outposts to British control.
With the return of peace, Fort Niagara’s garrison was reduced to around 150 men whose duties included guarding the Niagara portage, moving supplies and policing Indian traders. To guard against a Native attack on the reduced garrison, the British built two stone redoubts in 1770 and 1771.
In spite of these improvements, the Fort was in decrepit shape at the outbreak of the American Revolution in 1775. Over the next eight years, the British expended a great deal of effort and expense to improve the Fort and protect their link to the west. In addition to serving as Britain’s Great Lakes headquarters, the Fort became a haven for frontier Loyalists and Native American allies. From Fort Niagara, loyalist/Native raiding parties devastated the frontiers of New York and Pennsylvania, diverting much-needed manpower and supplies from George Washington’s forces fighting along the seaboard. When American forces counterattacked in 1779, Fort Niagara became a haven for thousands of Native American refugees. The British were ill prepared for this influx and hundreds of Native people starved or perished from exposure during the brutal winter of 1779-80.
At the conclusion of the Revolution Fort Niagara was supposed to be turned over to the new United States. Unresolved treaty disputes delayed the transfer however, and it was not until 1796 that American troops secured control of Fort Niagara. The British moved across the river and erected Fort George on the Canadian shore. Unfortunately Fort Niagara’s most formidable defenses faced east, away from the new threat. In addition, small garrisons and paltry resources resulted in rapid deterioration of the Fort’s defenses.
With the outbreak of the War of 1812 Fort Niagara found itself on the front lines of the conflict. In October and November 1812 Fort Niagara traded artillery fire with Fort George in furious but indecisive bombardments. Fire was again exchanged in May 1813, when U.S. troops successfully captured Fort George. By the end of the year however, American troops abandoned the Canadian shore and burned the town of Newark. The British reoccupied the ruins of Fort George and on the night of December 18-19, 1813 secretly crossed the river and captured Fort Niagara. The Fort remained in British hands until the end of the war.
In the 1820s the completion of the Erie and Welland Canals rendered the Niagara portage obsolete and Fort Niagara’s strategic value quickly declined. The garrison was withdrawn and only a caretaker watched over the Fort’s venerable buildings and walls. The Fort was regarrisoned from 1828 to 1832 but then once again deactivated until a new border crisis in 1837 prompted Congress to authorize improvements to the Fort. By the time these improvements were completed in 1843, the crisis had passed and Fort Niagara was once again only sporadically garrisoned.
During the Civil War, the Fort once again saw improvements as the Union worried about a British alliance with the Confederacy. Construction of new concrete and brick revetments began in 1863 but was not completed until after the war ended. The Fort’s artillery casemates were never armed and the new defenses were obsolete by the time of their completion. As an anticlimax, border tensions once again escalated in 1866 as rebels known as Fenians sought Irish liberation through the conquest of Canada.
The post-Civil War years witnessed a significant change in Fort Niagara. A garrison that arrived in 1865 found the Fort’s living quarters antiquated and virtually uninhabitable. Construction soon began on modern buildings situated outside the old fortifications. This was the beginning of “New” Fort Niagara, the area occupied by modern Fort Niagara State Park.
Continuous changes to New Fort Niagara allowed the post to survive well into the twentieth century. A 1,000 yard rifle range was constructed in 1885 and the Fort became increasingly useful for training purposes. Troops were prepared for the Spanish-American War of 1898 and the Philippine Insurrection of 1899-1901. The post also served as an officers training camp during World War One.
Despite all of the activity in the new Fort, Old Fort Niagara was in a sadly neglected state by the early 1920s. Lake Ontario had undermined the seawall protecting its northern flank and the French Castle was in danger of collapse. The surviving 18th century buildings were badly deteriorated. Fortunately, the old fortifications and structures had long been recognized for their historical value. A group of local citizens began to advocate repair and preservation. They formally organized the Old Fort Niagara Association in 1927 with the goal of saving the Castle. Cooperation between the Army and the Association permitted restoration of the other buildings by 1934.
New Fort Niagara continued as an active post. During World War Two, the Fort was used as an induction center and as a prisoner of war camp.
Fort Niagara was declared surplus in 1945 and many of the buildings were converted to temporary housing for returning veterans. Plans to convert the New Fort into a state park were developed in the late 1940s but the Korean War forced reoccupation of the Fort in 1950. Anti-aircraft troops were stationed there from 1952 until the base was decommissioned in 1963. Long-delayed plans to convert the area to a park were soon implemented and most of the garrison buildings were demolished in 1965-66 to clear ground for recreational purposes. Only a few structures remain. With the exception of the United States Coast Guard station adjacent to the Fort, the military history of this important site had come to an end.
Today, Old Fort Niagara welcomes thousands of visitors each year who learn about life on the Niagara Frontier during the early years of our nation.